Top TenPlates
EnglishEspañol

Caribbean · 18°28′N 66°06′W · Kitchen testing pending

Puerto Rico

Where a third of the cooking starts at a grater

The ten

Ranked by what people actually name first

  1. A dome of mofongo turned out of a wooden pilón, flecked with pork and garlic, a cup of hot broth beside it.Mofongo1 hr 40 minFried green plantain crushed in a wooden pilón with garlic, pork, and fat while it is still hot enough to smear — served with a cup of hot broth beside it.
  2. A roasted pork shoulder with dark blistered cuerito, scored in diamonds and carved to show the pulling meat beneath.Pernil7 hr 15 minChristmas pork in an apartment — a bone-in shoulder packed overnight with a garlic-oregano paste and recao sofrito, roasted long, then blasted for cuerito.
  3. A pot of orange-stained rice studded with whole pigeon peas, diced ham, and green olives.Arroz con Gandules1 hr 20 minPigeon peas and rice in one pot with recaíto, achiote oil, and pork, until the grains are stained orange and the bottom has a chance at pegao.
  4. Pasteles unwrapped from their banana leaves, the orange masa set around a dark pork filling, with tied packets stacked behind.Pasteles3 hr 30 minGrated green banana, plantain, and yautía, coloured with achiote and folded around a reduced pork guiso in a banana leaf, tied, and boiled. Not a tamal.
  5. Fried alcapurrias on a rack, deep gold and blistered, one broken open to show the orange masa wall and beef filling.Alcapurrias1 hr 55 minYautía and green banana masa, orange from achiote, smeared around cold picadillo and fried naked in deep oil until the crust blisters. Kiosco food.
  6. A bowl of asopao de pollo — soupy orange rice with a bone-in chicken thigh, green olives, and cilantro.Asopao de Pollo1 hr 25 minSoupy rice with bone-in chicken and sofrito — thicker than soup, wetter than arroz con pollo. Pull it off the heat before it looks right, because the rice keeps drinking.
  7. Bone-in chicken pieces lacquered in a thick rust-orange sauce with green olives and potato chunks, beside white rice.Pollo Guisado1 hr 55 minBone-in chicken braised in fried recaíto and tomato until the sauce clings in a rust-orange coat. If it runs off the chicken like soup, you cooked asopao weather.
  8. Thin steaks buried under a heap of collapsed golden onions in a caldero, sitting in dark glossy pan juices.Bistec Encebollado1 hr 20 minThin beef marinated in garlic, oregano, and sour orange, then cooked with more onion than seems decent until the onions collapse and become the sauce.
  9. A pot of pink beans in thick orange liquor with chunks of calabaza, ladled over white rice.Habichuelas Guisadas3 hrPink beans stewed in fried recaíto and smoked pork, with calabaza smashed against the pot until the liquor clings to a grain of rice instead of running off it.
  10. A turned-out white coconut tembleque dusted with ground cinnamon, glossy and holding its shape on a rimmed plate.Tembleque28 minA coconut-and-cornstarch pudding cooked to a nappe and chilled until it shivers on the plate. No eggs, no caramel, no dairy — the name is the instruction.

Three of the ten dishes here begin the same way: a green plantain or a root vegetable, and a tool that turns it into something you can build with.

Mofongo is fried green plantain crushed in a tall wooden pilón with garlic and pork. Alcapurrias are green banana and yautía grated raw into a paste, wrapped around beef, and fried. Pasteles are that same grated masa spread on a banana leaf, filled, folded, tied in pairs, and boiled — a dish that honestly takes a day, and that almost nobody makes alone. That is the point of it. The assembly line is the recipe.

Green starch is not a side dish on this island. It is the structure.

The seasoning base is recaíto, and it is green: culantro, cilantro, ají dulce, onion, garlic, sweet pepper, blitzed and kept in a jar in the fridge. The Cuban base a hundred miles west turns red with tomato; this one does not have to. Over that goes achiote oil — annatto seeds warmed in fat until it runs orange — which is colour and a little earth. It is not heat. Almost nothing on this list is spicy, and the ají dulce is named dulce for a reason.

The rest is pots. Pollo guisado, bistec encebollado, habichuelas guisadas, asopao: onions cooked further than you think, and then time.