Bullfoot Soup
The Saturday cauldron outside the roadside cookshop. Cow heel rubbed with lime simmers with split peas until the tendons turn translucent. Pumpkin, yam, corn and a whole Scotch bonnet go into the golden broth, followed by hand-rolled spinners and chunks of separately cooked sweet cassava.
- Prep
- 35 min
- Cook
- 2 hr 30 min
- Serves
- 8
- Difficulty
- Medium
Researched · Kitchen testing pending

On Saturday afternoons steam rises from the cauldrons outside cookshops on St. Thomas and St. Croix. Bullfoot soup, cow heel soup, is the islands’ restorative: cross-cut trotters simmered until their tendons and skin are liquid gelatin, with yellow split peas that break down into a thick golden base.
Pumpkin, yam and corn go into the cauldron as the heel softens. In the final minutes the spinners swell in the sticky broth, and separately cooked sweet cassava warms through without breaking up.
Soup
- 1.8 kg4 lbCow heels, cleaned, hair singed, in 5 cm rounds
- 3 large3 largeLimes, halved, for seasoning
- 200 g1 cupDried yellow split peas, rinsed
- 3.5 L15 cupsCold water
- 200 g1 largeYellow onion, in fine dice
- 8 cloves8 clovesGarlic, crushed to a paste
- 4 whole4 wholeSweet seasoning peppers, seeded and minced
- 4 sprigs4 sprigsFresh thyme
- 4 whole4 wholeAllspice berries, lightly crushed
- 1 whole1 wholeScotch bonnet, unpunctured, stem on
- 300 g2 cupsCalabaza or kabocha, peeled, in 3 cm cubes
- 300 g2 cupsCommercially packaged peeled sweet cassava with cooking directions, in chunks
- 300 g2 cupsYellow yam or sweet potato, peeled, in 3 cm chunks
- 2 ears2 earsSweet corn, in 3 cm rounds
- 20 g1½ TbspFine sea saltdivided
- 2.5 g1 tspBlack pepper
Spinners
- 200 g1½ cupsPlain flour
- 3 g½ tspFine sea salt
- 100 mlscant ½ cupCold water
Feet are almost all collagen
Cow heel is tendon, skin and cartilage with little muscle. Held between 88 and 93 °C for two hours the collagen unwinds into liquid gelatin that gives the broth its lip-coating body. Cooled, it sets solid.
Peas as the thickener
Husk-free split peas burst quickly and disperse their starch into the broth, turning it opaque amber without any roux.
The five tastes on this plate
Salt seasons the tendons and roots. Fat is the melted collagen. Acid is added at the table, lime wedges or pepper vinegar. Heat is the whole pepper's aroma, allspice, garlic and pepper. Umami is trotter collagen, dissolved split pea and sweet roots.
Equipment
- 8 to 10-quart enamelled Dutch oven, or an 8-quart pressure cooker
- Large basin, for scrubbing
- Spoon, for skimming
- Bowl and fork, for the spinners
A blackened cauldron over a coal fire outside the cookshop. Indoors, a big Dutch oven, or a pressure cooker that tenderises the heels in 50 minutes before the vegetables go in.
Method
Season the heels10 min
Start with cleaned, hair-free heel rounds from the butcher. Pat dry, rub with the cut limes and transfer straight to the pot.
Start with cleaned, hair-free heel rounds from the butcher. Pat dry, rub with the cut limes and transfer straight to the pot.
Extract the gelatin1 hr 55 min
Put the heels and split peas in the pot with the cold water and bring to a rolling boil. Skim the grey foam for 10 minutes. Add the onion, garlic, seasoning peppers, allspice and 10 g salt. Lower to medium-low, cover with the lid ajar, and simmer 1 hour 45 minutes, or 50 minutes under pressure, until the tendons are translucent and pulling from the bone and the peas have dissolved.
Bring heels, split peas and cold water to a rolling boil; skim 10 minutes. Add onion, garlic, seasoning peppers, allspice and 10 g salt. Simmer medium-low with lid ajar 1 hour 45 minutes, or pressure-cook 50 minutes, until tendons turn translucent and release from bones and peas dissolve.
Provisions and corn20 min
In a separate pot, thoroughly cook commercially packaged, peeled sweet cassava in fresh water according to the package. Drain and discard all its cooking water. In the soup pot, add corn, pumpkin, yam, thyme and black pepper. Set the whole Scotch bonnet on top and simmer 20 minutes.
In a separate pot, thoroughly cook commercially packaged, peeled sweet cassava in fresh water according to the package. Drain and discard all its cooking water. In the soup pot, add corn, pumpkin, yam, thyme and black pepper. Set the whole Scotch bonnet on top and simmer 20 minutes.
Roll the spinners8 min
Mix the flour and salt, add the cold water gradually with a fork to a stiff smooth dough, and knead one minute. Pinch off 15 g pieces and roll between the palms into tapered 8 cm fingers.
Mix the flour and salt, add the cold water gradually with a fork to a stiff smooth dough, and knead one minute. Pinch off 15 g pieces and roll between the palms into tapered 8 cm fingers.
Poach the spinners12 min
Drop the spinners into the simmering soup one by one. Simmer uncovered 10 to 12 minutes, stirring gently so they do not stick, until they swell and float. The pumpkin will half-melt and turn the broth golden. Lift out the pepper and thyme stems. Fold in the drained, cooked cassava just long enough to heat through. Thin with fresh water if needed.
Add spinners one by one; simmer uncovered 10–12 minutes, stirring gently to prevent sticking, until swollen and floating. Pumpkin should partly dissolve and colour the broth golden. Remove pepper and thyme stems. Fold in the drained, cooked cassava just long enough to heat through. Thin with fresh water if needed.
Season and serve
Taste and add the remaining salt as needed. Ladle into deep bowls so each has heel, corn, roots and spinners, with lime wedges.
Taste and add the remaining salt as needed. Ladle into deep bowls so each has heel, corn, roots and spinners, with lime wedges.
Sensory cues of doneness
- Visual: a thick golden-amber potage of translucent cow heel, yellow corn rounds, orange pumpkin, white cassava and floating ivory spinners.
- Auditory: heavy, viscous bubbling as the soup thickens.
- Olfactory: rich marrow, sweet corn, allspice, thyme, stewed pumpkin.
Check for thick golden-amber broth, translucent heel, corn, pumpkin, cassava and floating ivory spinners. Expect heavy thick bubbles and aromas of marrow, sweet corn, allspice, thyme and stewed pumpkin.
Storing it
Divide leftover soup into shallow containers and refrigerate within 2 hours (1 hour above 32 °C). The broth gels as it chills. Bring it back to a boil and heat the pieces through to 74 °C.
Troubleshooting
- Rubbery heels.
Under two hours. Cook until the tendons are fork-tender and jelly-like.
- Spinners dissolved into starch.
Dropped in early. The last 12 minutes only.
- Cloudy, off-tasting broth.
The first foam was not skimmed. Skim hard for the first 10 minutes.
Substitutions
One-to-one swaps, with the technique change each one needs.
Ingredient substitutions
| Ingredient | Replace with | Culinary impact and technique adjustment |
|---|---|---|
| Cow heels | Veal trotters, pig feet or smoked pork hocks | Hocks add smoke to the gelatin |
| Calabaza | Kabocha, butternut or sweet potato | The same dense sweetness |
| Yellow yam | Sweet potato, russet or taro | Starchy tubers that drink the broth |
Scaling
Half
900 g heels and 2 litres water in a 5-quart pot; still 2 to 2½ hours.
Double
A 16 to 20-quart stockpot at a gentle sub-boil for the community pot.
What to serve it with
- Crucian yellow Scotch bonnet and mustard pepper sauce
- Warm johnny cakes or hard dough bread
- Cold ginger beer, or hot bush tea
Questions
Ox feet or pig feet?
Pig trotters or veal feet work the same way; cow heel is traditional for its gelatin.
Why bullfoot if it is cow heel?
Old Caribbean usage: trotters from working oxen and bulls were bullfoot.
Why does it set in the fridge?
The gelatin. It turns back into broth on gentle heating.